Trying to sound auntie

I’ve been seeing Anne-Marie Slaughter’s essay floating around Facebook for the last few days – the famous name, in combination with the title clearly indicating a sensitive topic, told me it was certainly something worth reading but I didn’t have time to because shit was going down in other areas at the time.

Then yesterday my #2 sister-in-law forwarded me SIL #1’s relatively brief response to the email so I thought I should reply. It took me a while to get my thoughts organised since, as noted below, I’ve lost the habit of introspection and writing years ago. But anyway this is my two-odd cents. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Day 0: Tune Hotel

Enilit and I checked into the Tune Hotel near the LCCT (Low-Cost Carrier Terminal) and we found out just how budget it is (for an airport hotel). The room is pretty much a queen-size bed with barely enough floor space to walk around it to get to the bathroom. I’m not eve sure an obese person could live in here.
We were floating the idea of staying an extra night in Kuala Terengganu and taking the bus back to Singapore on Sunday instead of Saturday night. Since I’ve barely been to East Coast, I’m quite keen on the idea. One of the books I brought for this trip is Awang Goneng’s “A Map of Terengganu”; we’ll see what he has to say about KT. (The other book is an Amazon Vine reviewer’s uncorrected proof of “Kaltenburg” by some German writer whose name I don’t remember.)
We were lying down to sleep when Enilit suddenly found a battery-shaped lump under the sheet. Turns out there were three of them. My hypotheses are that they’re from a) a previous guest’s sex toy, although that doesn’t explain why under the sheet, or b) a cleaner’s torchlight and they forgot to collect the old batteries afte changing them.
Anyway that’s why I’m writing this now, because it was too funny not to record.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

Berkemban

When enilit and I left for our Redang trip two weeks ago, we bought cheap printed (but fairly nice) “batik” sarungs in the market in Kuala Terengganu, which ended up being really convenient for the beach. Mary, who had a man’s plaid sarung “because it’s bigger”, demonstrated how we could drape them over our heads and lie on the sand during turtle watch.
After a week of trying I still can’t tie a sarung properly, but in an attempt to look cute, I put it on after coming out of the shower. This dialogue with my husband followed:
“The innocent village maiden emerges from the river amid the morning dew.” (Actually I’m urban-raised and it was past midnight.)
“The American imperialist comes to ravish the women and take all the resources!”
“Good luck with that.”
“The women or the resources?”
“I have a bag of Snickers somewhere in this house and you’re never gonna find it!!!”
“The imperialist must turn the natives against each other! I’ll ask your sister where the Snickers is.”
“She doesn’t know either, ha ha.”
Actually they’re in my Crumpler bag and going to work with me to be my desk drawer emergency snacks tomorrow. Too bad for the imperialists.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Newspaper Rage II

image

How about just “Moronic”. We get it, your mummy-daddy or your elite JC or whatever made you study Western literature. This is assholic writing. The author goes on to talk about how Finland has done education its own way and been successful, completely failing to note that Finland’s egalitarian system is poles apart from Singapore’s cutthroat competition.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

The game of keep-away

Heaven knows I’m not a language prescriptivist. I’m one of those people who like using “they” in the singular on purpose because English lacks a gender-neutral 3rd person pronoun for adults. But I really can’t get my way around some of the annoying and weird ways Singaporeans use English (I’m from across the Causeway; grew up in an English-speaking family and went to Malay school so I suppose Chinese-ed Malaysians might do some of the same annoying things).

Like the use of “keep” for “put away” – this happened in the surgery waiting room when I went for Lasik last November:
Nurse: Keep your spectacles.
Me: OK. [Continues wearing specs]
[2 minutes later]
Nurse: I said keep your spectacles. Keep your spectacles in your bag!
Me: Oh…

Also, the use of “bullets” for “staples” and “zap” for “photocopy” makes office work sound quite violent. I wonder if any hapless US Americans or other US-educated foreigners mistakenly put some important documents in the shredder upon being told to zap them…

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Funny stuff from the Old Testament

A few months ago I started reading the book of the prophet Isaiah again, because there was a series of weekday evening talks at church. I stopped going after the first one because IMO the bishop was too boring a speaker and had too many weird pet theories about the structure of the book. I also disagreed with him that if, as modern scholars believe, Isaiah was written by more than one hand, that somehow is denying its validity, because if it’s inspired by God what does it matter how many people were inspired?

Anyway, I’m still trying to read through it on my own. The version of the Bible I currently use is the NET Bible in the CadreBible Android app. I found it worth paying for the full version because, while the translation is frankly awkward, where it shines is the massive amount of annotation on the translations and a bit on history and geography. While I may not agree that something needed to be paraphrased to make it understandable in modern English, at least there is something telling me clearly what the original phrasing was.

One of the interesting notes in the early part of Isaiah is on 7:20Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

ISEAS forum on shark fin industry

The record below is an UNEDITED ROUGH TRANSCRIPT typed on a mobile device. I have decided to sacrifice formatting for faithfulness in recording as fast as I can possibly type – it was transcribed “on the fly” and not from a recording. My personal comments are either bolded or in parentheses.

I later found out through readily available public information (just Google it) that Giam was ALSO an employee of Species Management Services and thus was not only on the same “side” of the debate as Jenkins, but from the same “team”. I am extremely pissed off at this deliberate deception by both of them and ISEAS’ either collusion in that deception or failure to look up some basic curriculum vitae information on their panelists. All of us who turned up innocently expecting a more or less honest discussion were lied to.

Featuring CITES committee member Giam Choo-Hoo, ACRES’ Louis Ng, 2 other panelists. Moderator: Tan Keng Jin.

Slide on basic shark taxonomy & biology
Other shark product uses: liver oil, shagreen leather for polishing wood & grating wasabi
Sacred to some Pacific Islanders; moderator recommended removing from Istana menu in case their diplomats visit.

Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 5 Comments

Ice fishing

Sere” isn’t a word one would use often in my country, but it well descibes my husband’s: withered, dry, just after the solstice of an unusually snowless winter that leaves the brown grass naked. Even though it has been mild enough this year that a few clumps of vivid green grass remain along Milwaukee’s Root River parkway, the land looks like I feel – dry and withered.

While I hate being cold, I’m rediscovering that it’s the darkness and aridity of winter that I really can’t stand. One can always bundle up against the cold, as I did in my snowboarder/bank robber outfit used for cycling in up to six inches of snow. There is no defence against having the moisture constantly sucked out of one’s body by the air (having had Lasik a few months ago, I’ve also realised that a function of spectacles is to protect one’s eyeballs from the wind) nor against the gloom that sets in at four and lightens only at eight, especially since Americans still like those jaundice-colored incandescent bulbs. I lived here for eight years, but shoot me if I ever go for another winter holiday.

Leave it to wealthy Singaporeans and KLites to splurge on ski vacations to Korea or Colorado. Since my family’s first stint in the USA, I’ve associated winter with death. Images of brightly-clad children running about in the snow are a meaningless cartoon to me. Snow is what you stamp about in to clear a tiny space while I wait in the dark for a bus that never comes, and the breath freezes in my lungs. Gopal Baratham wrote that for people in the tropics, a dream of winter is essential. The converse has been true for me during my long schooling and apprenticeship, and for the last two weeks.

In the midst of all this I dragged him out for a walk – like a parent extracting a pledge of good behaviour for Christmas presents, I agreed to his buying Skyrim on the condition of half an hour’s exercise a day. And in the midst of all this death and dormancy, we saw this:

image

A weasel, or something from the weasel family at any rate, which popped out of the withered grass and turned its cool, beady gaze on us for a long moment before diving through a hole in the ice like a miniature seal. We stared amazed as the blebs of its exhalations traced a minute-long circle across the frozen creek, then it clambered out and disappeared back into the grass. We waited as the rustling of its movement continued, and were rewarded with a repeat performance shortly. Poor weasel, neither dive yielded fish nor frog.

In what I feel as the deathly cold and darkness, some not only survive but still hope for prosperity. Happy New Year.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Why PAGE is wrong

Written to a family friend who forwarded PAGE’s latest email bulletin.

Someone very close to me did his/her undergrad thesis on PPSMI. I am not at liberty to share it but I understand it was highly praised by people who know what they’re talking about. As far as I can tell (my brain goes blank when I see tables of multivariable analysis), the take-home messages were a) we don’t have enough data because there was never a full cohort that did their entire pri/sec education under PPSMI (thanks to our goverment’s premature-ejaculation style of implementation of policy) b) the negative effects are slight but real c) the positive effects are inconclusive. If you’re reading this, kiddo, PM me if I misrepresented you.

———————————————-

Hi Aunty,

I actually disagree with PAGE even though I’m from an English-speaking family. I feel that the improvement of English should be done by improving the English curriculum and not by hijacking science and maths. As science and maths at the primary and secondary school level are still basic, first of all they should be taught in a medium which is EASILY UNDERSTOOD for all students. The goal of science and maths lessons is to convey science and maths concepts, not polish English skills. Understanding of science and maths among the Malaysian public is lousy, just look at the kind of things that journalists and readers
write in the newspapers. Putting the basic education in a language that many find difficult will make it worse. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The Budget and Its Shadow

Talk by Teh Chi Chang (REFSA, Research for social advancement based in KL). Background from financial industry.
Book: “Budget: How the Government is spending our money” pub last year.

1st year tt Pakatan has come out w Shadow Budget,previously only DAP

Income: bottom 40% avg rm1500/mo
Majority 80% rm2500/mo
>1/3 of household heads employed in informal sector
70% SPM qualification or lower
Inequality among highest in Asia

Debt:
2010 end rm577bn total household debt = 77% gdp
140% personal dispo income (us 123, sg 105, thai 53%)

Competitiveness:
Only country in Asean w net FDI outflows

Rising cost of living.initiatives 2 help
Kar1sma aid program
Kedai 1 Rakyat Msia
Menu 1 Rakyat Msia

Graduates – high unemployment, low skills

Response by gov:
Expand subsidies & handouts
Mega-projects to stimukate demand
-corridors, MRT, Warisan Merdeka
Talent Cortp, ETP, EPP, NKRA…

Subsidies massive
Now 18% gov revenue
2000 rm2.6bn to 2011 rm33bn
Above does NOT include subsidies to industry eg power producers, petrol
Have expanded to include Kedai 1Msia thrift stores& Menu 1Rakyat Msia meals

BN view: hardwaredrives growth
Public-private partenerships
Rural minor infrastructue
Corridors
Langkawi
KL financial district
Even in education, focus is on constructing schools
– for Class F (bumi) constructors only
– fails to address literacy, numeracy, work skills

Coddling businesses
Fill gaps in pte sector directly, even where financial industry has not seen fit to fund
Eg venture capital for creative industry
Islamic finance
Bumi entrepreneurs
SMEs *and* “second chance” funding for failed SMEs
Bank bailouts!!!

Civil servant 10% of workforce, 1.2M civ serv to 1.7M taxpayers
GLCs are 50% of economy
Natl debt rm430bn = 14800/every Msian
Has doubled since 2004.

HOWEVER, revenue has exceeded budget since 1998 except during 2008/9 econ crisis
So why is gov in debt? Spending has also exceeded budget consistently.
Budget deficit has been conspicuously worse last 3y.

Pakatan Rakyat basic framework:
Raise revenue bycurbing tax evasion
Spend money more effectively
Riase incomes by focus on soft infrastructure, not construction

GST not necessary yet -regressive tax bc currently only small % Msians pay income tax

Tax evasion:
APs: +1.8bn if auctioned, no extra cost to citizens.
Illegal trade: e.g. cigarettes 2bn. Gambling industry: illegal nearly same size aslegal

PR 220bn total spend same size as gov budget, but outcomes +20% by eliminating waste
Subsidies targeted to poorest 1/3(2M) households.
Current subisides: mainly petrol, rich benefit more
Kedai 1Rakyat – takes business from neighbourhood shops

Budget 2012 recd surprising amt criticism fr industry, 3rd parties eg Malaysia Rating Corp (MARC)

PR: reduce cost of living & business
Lopsided concessions & monopolies eg IPPs, tolls, lead to high costs.
PR proposes Unfair Public Contracts Act: create commission to review such contracts & can acquire/ expropriate.
Extend Competitions Act to all sectors – currently telcos, Astro, energy exempt.

Wages:
2 foreigners(documented and estimated undocumented) to 5 Msian workers. Mostly unskilled
Disincentive for pte sector to invest in raising worker productivity
Even Msians low education

PR proposals
Minimum wage rm1100
Reduce unskilled foreigners
Emphasise technical/vocational skills, make it a respected career path
Incentivise businesses

Facilitating entrepreneurship
Open procurement: rewards know-how, not know-who; reduce gov costs; reduce fees to middlemen
Current rank 113/183 countries in ease of starting business
Less red tape for rakyat eg filing taxes, renewing licenses.
Keep GLCs in key areas only. Too many GLCs not only reduce competitiveness, also cause conflcits of interest.(regulator vs business)

Gov “generosity” mainly benefits elite
7/10 poverty eradication progrmas failed due to overspending & not selective of recipients
PR: shrink PM’s Dept & reallocate $ to ministries & states

Resource use
Cap Petronas dividends
Better water management (savings, pricing) to avoid buidlding new dams
Improve transport infrastructure

Comparison:
BN budget overoptimistic on gov revenue & GDP, so even though both have similar deficits in $ and % of revenue, BN likely to run over.

Big picture: BN budget hands out plenty of fish for all, from the truly needy to Class F contractors.Shadow Budget plans to create a nation of skilful fishermen.
–end talk–

Francis Hutchinson (political economist) follow-up talk
Existential questions

Q1: does Msia need a new growth model?
GDP growth slowed after Asia econ crisis
Good overall enviro for business BUT a lot of other issues

Q2: new social model?
Poverty dropped tremendously over last 4 decades but Gini coefficient barely decreased
Worse than Phils, Indo, Iran, India, USA
Inequality leads to social problems

Q3: state-society model?
Accountability to ppl
Does Msia tax enough & aretaxes being used in productive way?
Most revenue from oil&gas revenue
How govts earn income v important for state-people r’ship: if revenue is from people, gov is highly motivated to make ppl prosperous, ppl are motivated to be engaged in gov.
(Our counterexample: imagine if Petronas Twin Towers, KLIA etcwere paid w income taxes.
Countries w large oil revenue assoc w weak democracy & rule of law

Q4: is Msia managing oil wealth responsibly?
In light of reserves soon to run out & growing population, should set aside some for future
Intergenerational equity

Gaps in 2012 budget: for industry
No help for manufacturing -needed for job creation esp middle class. High-skill sectors create relatively few jobs.
R&D: v littleexpenditure. Tied up in few niche institutes. Not enough in unis. Dispersed across pte sector
Sci & tech grads too few.
Infrastructure for innovation eg technical libraries, market info, labs & testing facilities.
Communication: not enough resources. SMECorp, SIRIM, NPC. Mostly concnetrated in KL

Social:
Best features probably expenditures for 2ndary education & abolishing school fees.
Civil svc: new salary structure, explicit promotion criteria. Increasescapacity, but what abt…
Size- vast expansions under Mahathir. Overlaps bet fed, state, corridor admins.
scope- gov intervention in too many sectors
accountability- e.g. water: until 2007, r’ship bet state gov & water provider direct. Now fed gov intervening, too many actors dilutes accountability.

Per capita fed gov spending is hugely disproportional for KL FT compared to states.

PR’s shadow budget: largely agrees w Chi Chang. Questions:
What sectors does PR gov want to invest in?
How to tackle inequality?
Are you happy w current tributary structure? – progressive taxes? Corporate vs income?
What relationship does PR see bet state & citizens?
–end talk–

Q&A session:

Q: Significant # of deserving poor/elderly/disabled etc not receiving assistance. But we don’t want to be stuck in welfare state, use some development programs eg Sg’s Workfare. Don’t go for cash transfer entirely.
TCC: there is not a proper database of needy in Msia. AG’s report highlighted aid misdirected to non-poor families. PR promises to consult w stakeholders on this.

Q(Barry Wain): 1. Pte investment supposedly surged last few years but I’m extremely sceptical, would like to ask you about this?
2.Govt providing cheap meals, who is being squeezed?
TCC:
1. Surge was starting from a low base. Gov figures are from MITI. Even with that surge, net FDI still negative.
2. 1Msia meals will most likely affect small traders. Eg coffeeshops, kedai runcit. Super/hypermarkets prob less affected bc catering to more wealthy.

Q/comment: 1. disagrees tt net investment outflow shows Msia not competitive. Could be showing tt Msian co’s competitive enough to invest abroad.
2. It’s a good thing tt Msia gov giving SMEs more chances.
TCC: 1. You may be right but issue is not whether Msian cos are strong or not. Question is why they are sending $ overseas? Eg passenger car mkt largest in ASEAN but automakers all moving to Thailand.
2. Issue w providing aid to failed SMEs is tt you end up socialising losses. How is aid structured? Ideally gov shd get investment back if it becomes profitable again. Also, gov shd b more conservative in stewarding taxpayers money. Not justifiable to invest in too-new/innovative product. Better to provide technical infrastructure tt can help whole industry.
FH: GLCs 50% econ, local SMEs only hv half the field to play in. To be viable they need to start exporting immediately.
2. In this part of the world, MNCs are much more profitable, SMEs do not want to b seen 2 have failed. Compare to eg Silicon Valley where failure is pt of career. If your co failed, means probably won’t work so shd not bail out SMEs twice.

Q: 1. Global labour market about 1/2bn people who are cheaper than Msia, how to deal with it? How much requires a political shift vs fiscal shift? 2. Institutions in Msia hv become diluted in last decade, how much do you think this plays in lack of competitivness?
TCC: 2. Foreign companies don’t trust judiciary, want disputed to be arbitrated in Sg. Other – police.
1. Productivity in Msia is low. Eg delivery of goods inefficient and tardy- drivers don’t have GPS. Bosses don’t care bc salary & fuel cheap.
Wain: many institutions simply don’t work, terrible situation when companies don’t trust courts.
Elephant in room: bumiputra policy. How much of a drag on economy is NEP(and its abuse)?
FH:
I look at electronics sector in my research. Ppl v worried about your #1 point in 2000-04. Co’s recruited to relocate from Penang to China. Worry has receded somewhat for managers wages, remains somewhat at lower skilled workers level. China problems: IP protection, labour unrest. Co’s don’t want to put all eggs in 1 basket. Msia also has few decades of developed capabilites. Manufacturers don’t want to pull out of established commitments. New front: Indonesia.
TCC:
As a result of misdirection, various inefficiencies in bumi policy perpetuated. E.g. APs distributed for free to bumi “entrepreneurs” (only 100-odd people) who did not import cars but simply sold them to the real car importers. Reason why auto industry reluctant invest in Msia.
NEM was to roll back some protections but right wing groups eg Perkasa protested, NEM has now been quietly shelved.
Prime tracts of land alienated to certain GLCs. Eg MRT project still doesn have cost estimate but has been given away.
FH:
Pg and Johor are centres for electronic industry but gov support is not oriented to manufacturing. Is given more to food&bev – disjunction.
Linguistic- older ppl in industry is a lot Chinese, not fluent in BM, English but most programs are in these languages.
Gov training programs give human capital but not social capital – focusing on certain ethnic groups only creates a barrier to growing those industries.

Q: subsidies per household quite substantial compared to income. By cutting down, why can’t Pakatan balance their budget? 2. AG’s report shows massive overspend, more room to cut.
TCC: can’t cut subsidies immediately. Will be retained for 1 year while working out how to proceed.

Q: what do you think of brain drain, Najib’s incentive of flat 15% tax for returnees? What else can be done? 2. What do you think of Iskandar?
TCC:
1. Don’t agree bc incentive for Malaysians to go abroad 1st to get low tax. Also, taxes not only thing driving Msians abroad. 6 years ago, similar initiative got substantial # back but only 1 left now. Other things: edu system, employment for talented.
2. Iskandar conceived in 2008, 3y later still planning? A lot of construction but hardly any institutions hv come in.
FH:
3-4 y ago Prof. Rajarasiah tried, horror stories on trying to get work permits & tax breaks (he’s the sole survivor of tt program).
Iskandar good if you are large co. & just need land, can integrate w Sg. If u r small & need investment, universities, other tech resources, no.

Q: are the overseas Msians tt gov is trying to get back from a certain demographic?
TCC: Talent corp not targeting any race. Across the board, successful Msians overseas incl bumis doing well & recognised in their work, don’t want to come back. If return to Msia, face stigma that “you’re here just bc you’re bumi”.

Q: one-line summary of 2 budgets?
FH: BN budget like American dessert, too sweet. PR budget like Japanese dessert, doesn’t hit your palate but you enjoy later.

Q(Ooi Kee Beng): when you study PR budget do you get a sense that it’s well integrated or just trying to grandstand?

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment